You may also like

5 from 21 votes (8 ratings without comment)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating




37 Comments

  1. Delaney C says:

    I wish this made a note about how long to whip the eggs and sugar until they’re “ribbon stage”. I kept whipping but was afraid I’d add too much air to the eggs, causing the cake to deflate later. I usually read what the recipe blogger writes ahead of the recipe to get extra guidance on directions, but these said pretty much the exact same thing as the recipe directions below, so it was not extra guidance on directions at all. It also tasted a little eggy.

    1. Whipping eggs with sugar depends on the size of the eggs, the thickness of the sugar as well as the mixer you use. If I use a hand mixer it takes about 4 minutes but in my stand mixer it usually less a little less than 3 minutes.
      Cakes will be less eggy if fresh eggs are used. You can also remove the eye of the egg to make baked goods less eggy.
      I do try as much as I can to give a detailed recipe with lots of tips across the recipe as well as FAQ and Troubleshooting.
      In fact, I add progress pictures as well as a video, so my visitors can make the recipe as successfully as possible.
      Sorry, it wasn’t detailed enough for you.

  2. No measurement for the Baking Powder. No mention of when to add the sugar. A waste of time and food.

    1. Hey Keren. Sorry about that. But, there is no leavening in this recipe, no baking powder or baking soda. The sugar is whipped with the eggs. Thanks

  3. The recipe doesnt even make one cake! And misleading recipe where the method doesnt include half the ingredients mentioned.

    1. Anusha. the recipe does make 2 cakes as you can see in the video. The bulk of the batter is whipped eggs. Most novice bakers don’t succeed in making this cake because they end up deflating the whipped eggs.
      If the eggs are deflated of course there will be no batter to bake (not even one cake). Please see the video below.
      As for the ingredients – I just checked the list and the method. Can you please be specific as to what is missing?
      Thanks

  4. I did everything right like followed the recipe but theres not even enough batter to cover 1cm of the cake pan the video instructions are also very dofferent from the recipe you wrote down. the cake completely colapsed. do not recommend.

    1. Hey Stella. Sorry, this did not work for you.
      The cake is a classic Genoise cake which is not the easiest to make.
      The main component of the cake is the whipped eggs. That’s what the cake is all about.. very little flour.
      If the beaten eggs get deflated which I think happened in your case there will be no batter left to bake the cake.
      I have re-checked the recipe again and the video and written recipe are the same.
      Thank you for the feedback

  5. Marisa F. Stewart says:

    5 stars
    What a beautiful cake. It is so feminine looking and the inside looks so light and moist. If my daughter sees this cake I know she’ll request it for her birthday. The touch of red strawberries really sets it off.

  6. 5 stars
    This looks like the perfect dessert for Spring or Easter. Lovely presentation and instructions to help even the novice baker!

    1. Love your recipes! I tried making it with the corn flour and the texture came out a bit grainy (perhaps I didn’t use the correct type of corn flour). Am I able to substitute the corn flour with all AP flour or is there a reason it needs to be corn flour?

      1. Keri cornflour/cornstarch is like flour consistency and it dissolved in water. Cornmeal is grainy and cannot be used for this. Flour makes this very starchy so cornflour works perfectly. You can also use tapioca starch or arrowroot.

  7. Arlene Mobley says:

    5 stars
    Wow, that frosting looks so like and fluffy.

  8. Hi veena, how much Baking powder to be added..It seems thats missing in the ingredients list.
    Thanks

    1. Hey Sha. There is no baking powder in this recipe. The eggs are the leavening in this recipe. Thanks