You may also like

5 from 58 votes (24 ratings without comment)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating




115 Comments

  1. Hi! I just made this cake in 3, 6 inch layers. I had to bake them for 30 min at 325 since at 20 and 25 min they were still undone/jiggling. Would you recommend next that I use cake rods? Or am I okay to bake for 30 min?

    1. Lexi, 6-inch cakes are not big so you don’t need cake rods. Every oven is different and it’s okay for the cakes to take up to 30 (35 mins) for baking.

  2. Nancy Gossett says:

    This is one of the hardest cakes I’ve ever made, but I’ve been baking for almost 60 years and I think I am fairly good in the kitchen and search many recipes for what I thought looked like the best ingredients and was up for the challenge. It is my granddaughters birthday and I told her to tell me whatever cake she wanted and she said red velvet Gigi, so the hunt was on. I have a very old recipe but it’s a little dry I believe. I have a fairly new viking range/oven that never fails me. I just made a lemon blueberry cake and two batches of cornbread, so I don’t believe it is the oven. I bake everything on the middle rack and the whole top of the cake was black within about 10 minutes. Do you have any idea why it would do this. I am just sick. I need to take a red velvet cake in the morning and it’s 8:30 at night. I feel like this recipe was a total pain and a waste of my time. So unless you can come up with a really good solution I will not be making this cake again snd would totally not recommend it.

    1. I’m sorry you had issues with this recipe, Nancy.
      Though, I don’t understand what the problem is. Do you have a question?
      If you can state the problem, I can help troubleshoot.
      The recipe is very popular on my blog and also very straightforward.
      Combine dry ingredients
      Combine (whip) wet ingredients
      Combine wet-to-dry ingredients
      Bake, Cool, and frost.

  3. 5 stars
    I’m surprised you don’t show the classic, original, and authentic frosting for a Velvet Cake, an Ermine Buttercream. Of the 6 classic buttercreams – American, Ermine, French, German, Swiss, and Italian – it’s the most stable, and I think the most delicious. It’s used in the south for 2 reasons, on all sorts of cakes, for a couple of reasons – it’s the closest in texture to whipped cream, and it holds up the best in the southern heat.

  4. Just to check, granulated sugar, not caster sugar? Thanks

  5. Does the cooking time change if using a 9×13 sheet pan?

    1. It should take about 25 to 30 minutes but of course, check to make sure a toothpick inserted in the center comes out clean.

  6. 5 stars
    I wish I could share a picture! This was the best ever red velvet velvet cake I have ever made! So delicious, moist, tender, great chocolatey taste! Thank you so much for this recipe! Love love love♥️

    1. Hey Nivi. Thanks. Happy you enjoyed this recipe. Yes, please share a picture in our Facebook Group so others will be encouraged to try the recipe too. Thanks

    2. Hi Veena, is this frosting suitable for a fondant covered cake? Thanks x

    3. Hi
      I made this red velvet cake but it was bitter; what did i do wrong
      Pls help

      1. Bitter? There is no ingredient in there that would make it bitter. Please check the gel food coloring.

  7. Kristy Wengert says:

    5 stars
    The texture is perfect of this cake! I love all of Veena’s recipes as when I follow her directions (especially her PRO TIPS) I always churn out something awesome! Thank you!

    1. Thank you so much Kristy for the lovely feedback. I am so happy you are enjoying my recipes.

  8. Best Red Velvet Cake EVER!! So moist. I think it is the oil! Thanks Veena

  9. 5 stars
    Hi,
    Veena i have tried your redvelvet cake recipe and it was a super hit everyone liked it ….Thank you so much for the recipe ,can’t express how grateful I am for sharing such a delicious recipes with us….

  10. Hie Veena…Really loves your way of cooking and baking Today I was making cream cheese frosting but as i mixed the ingredients (all room temperature),it curdled n was runny.What have I done wrong and how can I fix it?

    1. Mahvish. You must ensure the cream cheese is room temperature other wise it will curdle.