You may also like

4.99 from 70 votes (44 ratings without comment)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating




87 Comments

  1. Madison Abernathy says:

    I’ve made curd before, always lemon and using a different recipe. I thought I’d try this one with the mandarin oranges I had. I read all the instructions thoroughly. I had the hot water pot on low after boiling the water underneath it. It took 30 minutes to get to the point of coating the back of the spoon. By the time I got to the last cubes of the butter it barely melted in the curd. I did not strain it–maybe I should have. I never have strained my curds in the past and they have always turned out beautifully. The taste is very bitter, and the curd has almost a gritty texture. I’m not sure what happened. It also didn’t set up as firmly as I thought it would–it’s halfway between runny and spreadable. I may go back and strain it today. Maybe this is what is making it taste so bitter, I’m not sure. I might give this recipe a try again, or just go back to my old faithful so much for this to taste great!!

    1. Madison, I am sorry to hear that you did not have success with this recipe. This is a very popular recipe and many have had success with it.
      1. Yes, you need to cook this on medium to low heat but you still need to have enough heat to cook it. Sounds like your double boiler was not getting any heat.
      2. The taste of the orange curd will come from the orange juice you use. The only addition we have is sugar, butter, and eggs – none of these make it bitter.
      As I said in the post -when juicing the oranges avoid the membranes and seeds these can impart a bitter flavor.
      3. The straining of the curd will only take away any curdled eggs to give you a smooth velvet-like curd.
      If you had membranes or seeds cooking in the curd they have already done their job of imparting some bitterness.
      This is a no-fail recipe because cooking in a double boiler prevent curdling which usually happens easily.
      Thanks for the feedback. I will keep a close eye for more feedback

  2. Hi, This recipe was super easy and oh my!!!! The taste is so sinful!! ?. I will definitely try out your lemon curd recipe.

  3. 5 stars
    Love it – thanks for the recipe

  4. Charmaine says:

    Thanks so much, I’m going to try this today for a chocolate orange cake km making this weekend. I. Curious about freezing though, what vessel would you recommend freezing it in, is a jar ok?

  5. Denise Fleming says:

    5 stars
    followed recipe exactly as written. Took very long to thicken up. But the taste was delicious

    1. 5 stars
      I am so sorry to hear it took long to thicken Denise. Perhaps the heat was too low? Happy it was delicious

      1. Hi Veena, the taste is very good and texture is nice (I may not have thickened it quite enough, but it’s satisfactory) but there is a chalky finish, presumably from the cornstarch. Any idea why this might have happened?

        1. Hey Sho, if you do not cook the curd long enough it will not thicken and it will not cook the cornstarch which ends up with what you called chalky taste. The cornstarch needs to be really cooked well for it to become opaque, thicken, not taste like flour

  6. 5 stars
    Hi. I amde this recipe using Mandarins as we have a lot here in spain at the moment. The ones I used were very tart so I did not use lemon juice but upped the mandarin juice by 4 tbs. The recipe was super easy and the result was great. I usually use abother lemon curd recipe but I will be trying yours next time I make.

    1. Thank you, Diane. Personally, I do love tart oranges for my orange curd. Sounds delicious. Happy to know you liked this recipe. Thank you for coming back to write this feedback. love to hear from those who try my recipes.

  7. Could I use powdered/confectioner’s sugar instead of caster sugar? If so, what would the measurement be?

    1. Hey Alina. I have not used powdered sugar so I can’t tell you much. I’d say use the same amount. I’d love to know how it was if you do try it with powdered sugar. Thanks

  8. Can I use the juice from frozen orange juice concentrate? I’ve made lemon curd many times using fresh juice and I’ve also tried yet failed making orange curd using fresh juice. I don’t have any oranges on hand but would love to try this recipe. Really hoping to finally find an orange curd recipe that actually tastes like orange without having to add an extract, liquor or essence…

    1. Hey Tammie. I have not tried using commercial orange juice.
      I usually do not recommend these when it comes to baking so I’m not able to tell you for sure.
      Some commercial brands have additives that can give a weird after taste and flavor.
      You can make a small batch and try if you want. Sorry, I don’t have a definite answer for you.
      Thanks

  9. 5 stars
    Excellent! Bookmarked recipe. Texture is PERFECT and taste is wonderful.

    1. Thank you, Ariane. So happy you enjoyed this recipe. Thank you for coming back to write this feedback.

  10. 5 stars
    My experience with this recipe (NOT reflective of the poster- the directions were great, and I love when posts are short and to the point!) I spent 20 minutes with double boiler on low (set at 2 out of 8 on my burner). No cooking. Upped it to 3/4 out of 8 for 10 minutes. Still below 120 degrees. Upped it to 6 (out of 8!) for 10 minutes. Curd got to 130 degrees. Went to 7 for 5 minutes, curd did not get above 135 degrees. I finally just gave up the cooking portion, as it was relatively thick and not curdled and I was afraid if I went any higher it would curdle. I tried to then strain, using a pasta strainer as that is all I have on hand (so this has bigger holes than a fine mesh strainer)- would not strain through. I did a spoon lick test and it tastes pretty good, like I would expect a curd. I just went into this thinking 20 minutes and here I am over an hour later…..

    1. Hey Ashley, sorry your orange curd didn’t turn out well.
      Not sure what the setting on your double boiler is but as you can see in the video for lemon curd that I have shared, you still need the heat to be enough to cook the mixture.
      The lemon curd video is the exact recipe with only orange juice instead of all lemon juice.
      The reason I emphasize on low heat is that lemon is acid and can curdle just as easily as high heat can.
      In your case, it sounds like your curd was not cooking because it was barely getting any heat.
      Many people have tried this recipe successfully and I have made it more than a few times so this is a test and tired recipe.
      Sorry, it didn’t work for you. Have a great day.