You may also like

5 from 43 votes (8 ratings without comment)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating




155 Comments

  1. reema gurjar says:

    Hello, i was planning to try this recipe in the next few days, however do not own a stand mixer. Will it whip well with a hand mixer?

    1. Hey Reema. Yes, many people do use a hand mixer. You just have to whip it longer.

    2. Reema Gurjar says:

      Hey there, I tried this recipe and it worked out great. Smooth and shiny SMBC ? BUT it noticed that it wasn’t sweet enough. Is that how it’s supposed to be? Or should I add more sugar? Will that change the consistency of the SMBC eventually?
      TIA
      REEMA

      1. Hey Reema. The main reason people love meringue buttercreams is that they are less sweet. But you can add more sugar next time when you make it. Now for this recipe, it would be best to add a few tablespoons of powdered sugar so it incorporates well.

  2. ISHwarryah says:

    Hello,

    First of all big fan of ur creations.. my best wishes..

    I have done Swiss meringue buttercream before and it worked well. This time it loosened up and became liquidy as I started adding the butter. I stopped and refregirated the mix and tried whipping again. But it didn’t work. Can I fix it ? I have not added all the butter. Can I make any thing else with this?

    1. Thank you, Ishwarrayah, Sounds like the mixture was very warm when you added the butter. If the meringue is too warm it can deflate all the air in the meringue when you add the butter. I suggest chill it for a long time and then try again using a paddle attachment. It may not whip the big volume back up but it will still whisk creamy and smooth. I hope this helps.

  3. 5 stars
    Hi, Veena.
    I’m in love with your Italian meringue butter cream recipe so I’ve been using it so far.
    You seem to prefer this Swiss Meringue butter cream so I want to try this one.
    Hmm but is there any reason you use 100 g of more sugar compare to ITBC?
    Does this process require more sugar to yield the same result as Italian cream?
    Thank you!

    1. Hey Kay, no you can use 200 grams of sugar. In fact, I changed it so they are both the same.

  4. Stephanie says:

    5 stars
    Hi Veena, first off thank you for the video and in depth write up on the SMBC. I live in humid Malaysia & I gave your recipe a go. The meringue was going great till the butter went in. I waited for the meringue to cool but the butter part is a bit tricky here cuz at room temp my butter is very soft. So I put in the butter when it’s not too cold or too firm. But it just won’t whip up. So I put the whole bowl into the fridge for a couple of hours & whip it up again. It’s fluffy & spreadable but not stiff & feels greasy. Thing is, when layered between the cake it slides off. I have to refrigerate the cake for a bit but even so it just won’t keep the layers together & gets soft very quickly. What am I doing wrong? Thank you

    1. Hey Stephanie. It’s not you, and not your doing anything wrong. It’s the weather. Humidity is a huge problem for me here in Israel too.
      So in summer, I prefer to use only Ganache or my Velvet American Buttercream.
      Even if I manage to keep the SMBC in the fridge I can’t guarantee how my customers will store it.
      You see egg whites are like whipped cream. In very hot summer and high humidity, it collapses. That’s what’s happening for you too.
      That slipper meringue is a sign of meringue losing volume
      Sorry not sure I helped much

      1. Stephanie says:

        Thank you so much. That really helped. The fact that it’s not me.?. I normally use ABC & if holds up well here. Thanks for the recipe suggestions.Still the cakes sold at the bakeries seem to hold their layers well. I can only guess that their cakes are lighter /spongey that’s why the layers don’t split. My cakes are dense more like pound cakes. What do you think?

        1. You must try my Velvet American Buttercream, I think you will like it.
          Are you sure the bakeries are using SMBC? Often bakeries use Bakery-style frosting or non-dairy whipped topping so they can keep it longer.
          And yes, bakeries often use light sponge cakes similar to the Genoise cakes . That’s often because they use the light frostings I speak of above.

          1. Stephanie says:

            Thanks again for the prompt reply. I only assume the bakeries use SMBC so I guess you’re probably right. I think I will give your Buttercream a go. Thank you again. I appreciate it.

  5. Rachel Dinis says:

    I made the SMBC twice for my Macarons. It was very tasty. But I’m doing something wrong and not sure what. Both times it didn’t pipe very well, and there was chunks of butter, and it was very wet when left out so it made the cookies soggy. Over all it was very good and I want to perfect my technique and not give up. I don’t think the butter was soft enough, and I couldn’t get the meringue to a hard peak even after 30 minutes of beating with the hand mixer. I’m getting a stand mixer soon, so I can use that instead. Any tips are much appreciated!

    1. Hey Rahel. Happy you enjoyed this recipe. I love SMBC in macarons too.
      Definitely sounds like the butter was too cold so it didn’t’ blend well.
      The butter needs to be room temperature not melted but soft so it will blend into the meringue.
      If you didn’t get the meringue to whip well means there was probably grease in the bowl or whisk. Any grease will prevent eggs from whipping up.
      It there was liquid, it sounds like the protein in the meringue was separated a bit. Cream of tartar actually helps prevent that.
      I hope these tips help. I’m sure the next batch will be perfect.

  6. Hello Veena. I need urgent advice please. I made SMB and it was fine I stored it in fridge for a day, took it out today and left it for about an hour or so. It was a little hard so I used an electric hand whisk and it’s gone a little watery, curdled and yellow again. I had to decorate a cake tonight. But can try and do it tomorrow. Can I rescue this and how? I was going to do an ombré effect and tried using a paddle attachment with the coloured SMB and that’s had the same effect. Where have I gone wrong?
    Please advise. Otherwise I’ll just make normal buttercream and use that tomorrow.

    1. Hey K. Sounds like it got thawed too much? Could that be it? Also, did you use butter or margarine?
      Ideally, if you take it out and use the electric mixer it should not curdle. Sounds like the egg protein in the whites has separated.
      But place it back in the fridge for a few minutes until it cool but not cold
      Then whip it. Alternatively, place a bowl of ice water under the buttercream bowl and whip with the hand mixer until it comes back to consistency.
      It’s late night here so I may not be able to respond quickly but do let me know if this helped.
      All the best.

  7. Hello Veena. I have looked at your SMBC recipe/method and think of having a go at it. You have given the recipe using egg powder (I have some to use up) but here in the UK we can also get egg whites which are pasteurised. I am guessing I could use it in place of egg whites?
    Also would it work if I want to make a watercolour cake?

    Thank you for always responding. I am truly appreciative.

    1. Hey K, You can use my SMBC with meringue powder to use up the egg white powder. I have not tried doing a watercolor cake yet so not sure if it will work. Can’t think of why it won’t but since I’ve not tried – I can’t say for sure. Would love your feedback if you try it out.

  8. I’m going to try a SMBC soon. One variant I didn’t see was Nutella. It’s not quite peanut butter because it’s so sweet … can I adapt your recipe with some amount of it?

    1. Hey Laurie, Yes, you can make Swiss Meringue Nutella with this as well. I’d suggest the same 1 cup Nutella per 4 to 6 cups buttercream. You can reduce about 1/2 sugar in the original recipe to reduce the sugar if you want ( I do that as well) The more Nutella the darker the frosting and sweeter it gets too.
      I do have a Nutella Buttercream Recipe from scratch as well – but it’s not meringue-based.

    2. Thanks Veena, please can butter be replaced with margarine in SBCM?

      1. I do believe you can use margarine and some have done that successfully. I have never tried it

  9. Steffanie says:

    Hi. My SMBC is a little too greasy. Is there a way I can fix this? I put it in the refrigerator for now. Thank you 🙂

    1. Hey Steffanie.
      As I explained in the post under tips and troubleshooting.
      When whipping the warm eggs, start on medium and move to high speed. Let the meringue whip to stiff peaks. If not, they will lose volume when you add butter giving you a very greasy buttercream.
      Now, when you take it out of the fridge (make sure it not too stiff) whip with a paddle attachment. If the meringue is ok you should have a nice whipped cream consistency SMBC.
      If the have only butter in the bowl.. sweet and greasy. You can choose to make an American Buttercream frosting.
      Add powder sugar for every 1 stick buttercream add 2 cups powder sugar (yes, basic buttercream is sweet)
      So, either way, don’t throw it. It’s still useable.
      I hope this helps. Please let me know how it goes.

  10. Arundhati Barua says:

    5 stars
    Hi Veena, which buttercream is suitable to use under fondant covered cakes? Here in India mostly people prefer the whipped cream frosting since it’s less sweet. Until now I was using American buttercream and I had no trouble leaving the cake outside once it’s covered in fondant. But the thing is it’s too sweet and feels gritty!!! Would smbc/imbc hold well under fondant outside fridge in warm weather?

    1. Hey Arundhati. You can use meringue buttercream under fondant. It is less sweet than American buttercream. If you live in how and humid weather then ganache would be the best of course. The advantage of American buttercream means is that it can stay out in hot humid conditions longer.