You may also like

5 from 43 votes (8 ratings without comment)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating




155 Comments

  1. 5 stars
    Veena, thank you for the detailed explanation and the pictures which surely makes it easy for someone trying smbc for the first time. I have always hesitated to try it but now I question myself why did I wait so long!!
    I had frozen the smbc for 2 weeks and used it today and got a nice finish but the weather is warm so I could see the bc sweating. I have popped it backin the fridge to chill again before I wrap in fondant. I’m just concerned that it will melt under the fondant. Any tips? Thank you

    1. Hey Alita. Thank you, So happy you had success with this recipe. I find it hard to eat American buttercream once you get used to SMBC. You can keep a fondant cake in the fridge as well however if you experience very high humidity then be careful as some the fondant can get very wet with condensation. I suggest you do fondant on a chilled cake. You may need to work fast if the weather is warm but usually, even in this middle eastern hot weather my SMBC never melts away. Cranking up the Ac does help

  2. Krysta Bilodeau says:

    I’ve made two batches that are double batches. The first I threw out, the second is in the fridge from last night. Help me please. I’ve made this multiple times and never had this soupy mess. I made sure that it was cold before I added the butter, but obviously something went wrong.

    1. Kristya – Aww I’m sorry to hear that. The soupy mess is a result of adding butter before the meringue is cooled. The butter melts in the warm meringue creating a soupy mess. I explained it in the post too.
      You say you have one in the fridge? Well, don’t throw it.
      Put it back on the mixer and whip it!! Yes, Whip it.
      Now, take note… If the buttercream is stiff in the fridge do not use the whisk attachment – use the paddle attachment for the first two minutes then switch to whisk when you think the mixture is not stiff.
      Whip it and it should come back to a nice whipped meringue consistency.
      let me know how it worked.

  3. Shannon Mansell says:

    5 stars
    Hey Veena I love your recipes & always default to urs 1st before trying any others. Tried the SMBC for 1st time ever. Watched video & read recipe sev times. Waited until mix & bowl felt cool B4 adding butter. It’s smooth, pretty & light but tastes like butter. I dbl checked quantities & used ur specs: 1.5C gran sugar, 6 egg whites & 1lb butter (& 2 tsp vanilla). Idk what I did wrong!? The butter had salt in it but I dbl checked ur notes to make sure it was ok. Can u please help? I’ve gotta take the cake to church tonight. The SMBC is in fridge for now. TIA
    Shannon

    1. Hey Shannon. Meringue buttercream is usually very buttery. Compared to most SMBC recipes online my recipe has extra egg white. So the recipe is ok. If the meringue did not fail then you have what is suppose to be SMBC. My buttercream is a little less sweet because I added 1/2 cup less sugar but it works best with custom cakes.
      Have you tried whipping it again? It should be smooth, light and buttery. Unlike American buttercream which is sweeter than buttery, this is buttery.
      If you still think you don’t like it. Make a batch of American Buttercream and combine the two together. You will love it.
      I hope this reply comes in time for your cake. Sorry if I’m late. Just saw it.

  4. Arielle Rios says:

    Well this was a total disaster both times in a row for me. It ended up being a greasy mess that I had to trash, not icing consistency at all. Such a bummer

    1. Aww, why did you throw it Arielle? Sounds like you added butter to the meringue before it got cold. Like I say in the post, look at troubleshooting tips. If you add butter before the meringue is cooled the butter will melt and make a soupy mess. You can still recover it by simply chilling the whole bowl in the fridge until it’s cooler then whip the heck out of it again. It will gain volume and be fluffy again. Sorry it didn’t work for you.

  5. 5 stars
    I love SMBC but have always had issues with it when making it. This was my first successful effort and that’s because you explained so well. Thanks for the trouble shoot tips

    1. Thank you, So happy to hear you had success with this recipe. So happy you found my troubleshoot and tips useful. Thank you for coming back to write this feedback, appreciate it very much. Always a great feeling to read such success and positive comments. Thank you.

  6. Rachna Jhunjhunwala says:

    5 stars
    Hi Veena ,
    Thanks for the recipe was wondering if the SMBC works fine for piping roses and other flowers for like a flower wreath cake etc ? A lot of bakers on their tutorials say they are using that .. but won’t it be too melty for India ? Also can we make SMBC with shortening and butter ? Would that make it more stable for the flowers ? Whatever I do I am not able to make a non gritty buttercream when I use icing sugar … so you know of an Indian brand of sugar that works ? Thanks

    1. SMBC does work for roses and flowers for sure. It all depends on the weather really. If you enjoy good weather the roses will turn out beautifully. If you live in a hot and humid climate the buttercream tends to become a bit soft. So if you are in India I highly recommend using my stiff buttercream icing. Here in Israel I only use SMBC if I’m in the A/C and keeping the cake in the fridge in summer. The gritty buttercream is probably the quality of powder sugar. Some powder sugar made from beet sugar tends to stay grainy – find one that is made from cane sugar.

  7. 5 stars
    If your recipe of this SMBC yields 500gms, how many cups can this make? I will be frosting 3 doz of cupcakes, will one recipe be enough?

    1. Olivia it depends on how much you pipe on it. If you do just simple swirls it might be just enough. When I pipe I make tall cone type swirls so I usually would use more.

  8. 5 stars
    I want to try this recipe therefore I would like to try on a snallet quantity. Can u please help how to go about it?

  9. 5 stars
    Hello veena,
    I want to practice the smbc just to see how it turns out and the taste etc therefore I want to make a small batch. Can I halve the recipe or if u could give me someother ratio to try on. Thanks

    1. Yes you can half the recipe Kanwal. For me this is a small recipe already so I don’t usually half it. But I know some who have made half for cupcakes.

    2. Nga Tarai says:

      Hi there,
      So I thought I would give it a go and everything was good up until I added butter. My bowl was very cool to touch so o started adding the butter, so now it looks lumpy from the butter and it also looks like it’s curdling. I put it the fridge and decided to message you for any tips to make it like the picture.. LOL. Help please. All the way from NZ

      1. Hey Nga, sorry just woke up to your message. Good that you put it in the fridge. Now place it back on the mixer but with a paddle attachment. If its too hard wait for a few minutes to thaw. You want the butter very cold but not set. Then whip it for a good 3 to 5 minutes until it’s all light and fluffy again. It will work don’t worry.

  10. Tripti sharma says:

    5 stars
    Can you please tell me some vegan options or some egg replacer??