You may also like

5 from 43 votes (8 ratings without comment)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating




155 Comments

  1. Hi Veena,
    This is my second attempt -unfortunately even after cooling the meringue while adding the butter it seems to have curdled – I really wanted to master this as is looks light airy and is less sweet. Can this be overwhipped? it seems to have separated/curdled. No idea where Im going wrong.

    1. Matilda, is it separating when you are adding butter to the meringue or a few minutes after all the butter is whipped. If necessary keep the meringue in the fridge for 5 to 10 minutes to cool it off.

  2. Usha Gnanananda says:

    Hi mam… I tried swiss meringue buttercream today…i m not getting stiff peaks pls help

  3. Thanks for your recipes, I really appreciate. Please can I use the paddle attachment to whip my egg whites? For now I only have Kenwood hand mixer.

    1. You can use a hand mixer but you have to whip it for much longer until you whip the meringue – but it can be done

      1. Thanks Ma’am for your prompt reply. Please can I use margarine for SMBC?

  4. Hi Veena,
    I tried to make this SMB. Everything was wonderful until I started adding the butter. I think my butter was too soft if that makes a difference. It started looking like yellow cottage cheese. Now it’s creamy like creamed butter and doesn’t taste like anything. Do you know what I did wrong and is there a way to fix this?

    I was in your master class but missed the last few days because family kept coming in unexpectedly. I am trying to finish the class assignments.

    Thank you for your help and your tutorials.

    1. Yes, Tina. You added the butter too soon while the meringue was still warm. Just place it in the fridge for a few minutes (15 to 20 minutes) then whip it until its light and airy.

  5. Hi!
    Thank you!! I’ve always wondered how people make big, fluffy frosting that isn’t too sweet. I’ve only ever made the regular buttercream with powdered sugar. When I found out about using egg whites and regular sugar, I was intimidated – plus, I don’t have a candy thermometer. So, thanks for making it easy and totally do-able with my little hand mixer and the finger/smoothness test. Came out great!! I’m so excited – a whole new world is opened up…
    : )

    1. Thank you, Jennifer. I am so happy you found this recipe useful. Enjoy making frostings.

  6. 5 stars
    Light and silky. Every fork was licked clean…The whole family enjoyed it!

  7. Hi, is it ok to double the recipe or does it need to be made in two batches?

    1. You can make one batch if you are confident and done this before. If not, I would make two batches just to avoid any waste of ingredients.

  8. Hi!! I tried out this recipe but I think it’s really grainy, is there anything I can do?

    1. Ariana. Grainy? It will only be grainy if you do not dissolve the sugar when warming the eggs at the beginning. Ideally. the sugar would have dissolved by the time the meringue is ready. What sugar are you using? If you whip some more perhaps it will help the sugar dissolve

  9. I am making a wedding cake and want to know if you have ever fully frosted a cake in SMBC and then frozen it? Does the fully frosted cake thaw well? or does the frosting get weird? I know you can do this with buttercream, but I don’t have any experience freezing a frosted SMBC cake. I am looking to save time wherever possible, but obviously the cake needs to look good too 🙂

    1. Hey Hannah. Sorry, no I am not a huge fan of freezing frosted cakes. I usually freeze cake layers and then frost them when I need the cake.

  10. I started adding the butter after hours of (on and off) whipping with a hand mixer, yet the meringue barely had soft peaks. I made sure none of the equipment had grease, the egg whites were perfectly separated, and even added cream of tartar a few times. It’s been in the refrigerator several times for several hours but does not stiffen up when re-whipped. Left standing, it’s soupy and bubbly. It’s very humid where I live, is there any hope to save it?

    1. It should whip if you have chilled it for long Amanda. Chilling works for everyone. Sounds like the meringue is broken down with the grease. If it still does not whip after so much chilling I’m afraid it may not work. The humidity may be the cause for sure. I’m sorry but I don’t have any other suggestions because I don’t want you wasting any more resources on it.

      1. Thought so 🙁 Thanks for the quick advice!