You may also like

4.90 from 64 votes (23 ratings without comment)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating




149 Comments

  1. Bob Garrett says:

    5 stars
    Hi,
    I have just made this bread, I only did half size as I am trying to keep the carbs down which did not happen once I tried it.
    I left it for 21 hours and it hardly rose so I was a bit worried, I think the yeast is quite old so will be trying it with new stuff. In the oven though it rose to around 3 times the size. The dough was very sloppy and the best I could do was roll it around in the flour and scoop it up with a pair of scrapers and drop it in the tin.
    Just a thought, could you add cheese to the recipe.

    1. Thank you for the feedback, Bob. Yes, no-knead doughs are usually quite difficult to work with due to the lack of gluten development. You can definitely add cheese to this bread. The taste is absolutely delicious. You can even make garlic butter bread with this one.

  2. Cynthia Adams says:

    My dough has barely risen after an hour on the counter and. four hours in the fridge. Any thoughts?

    1. Cynthia sounds like you need to check the yeast. Also, if the weather is cold, it will take longer to rise. But, by 4 hours it should have risen well.

  3. Have you ever made this bread with whole wheat flour? Wonder how the recipe should be adjusted for it.

  4. Carmen Smith says:

    5 stars
    I’ve made this bread twice and both times it was absolutely superb!

    1. Thank you so much, Carmen, for the lovely feedback. Appreciate you coming back to leave this comment.

  5. Hello, is the oven temperature fan forced or normal ? thanks 🙂

  6. 5 stars
    so easy and so delicious!
    Thankyou for sharing this!

  7. I have 2 questions. 1) Can I use pie pans instead or an 8′ cake pan? 2) What changes do I need to make this in high altitude? Thank you so much for your help!

    1. Annie – You can use a 9-inch pie pan for this.
      I don’t bake at high altitudes so I honestly don’t have any experience baking bread at high-altitude.
      However, this site/post has some good information that you might find useful.
      Sorry, I can’t be much help in this.

      1. 5 stars
        It was my first time to make no-knead bread. I bake a lot using my bread machine but I love this kind of bread and I’ve wanted to try this for sometime now. This is a great recipe. I improvised a lot though. I did not put it in the fridge, and let it proof inside the oven for six hours. Then I shaped the dough, added raisins and walnuts, let it rest for another two hours, then bake as instructed. My bread was a perfect walnut and raisin crusted bread!

        1. Thank you, Marby. I am so happy you enjoyed this recipe. Thank you for coming back to leave this feedback.

  8. Jennifer Oh says:

    I measured everything with a scale the dough was so wet I couldn’t shape it. Not sure where I went wrong.

    1. Jennifer its ok to add a little more flour. All flour absorbs water differently so it’s ok if you add a little more flour or water as needed. Thanks

  9. Rhoda Murphy says:

    5 stars
    This is amazing!! First time making bread and we ate the whole loaf of bread in one sitting! #noshame

  10. Lee-Anne Sanderson says:

    I tried the mix the. Flour with the yeast mixture and there must be a mistake with the water ! 4 cups of flour and 1 3/4 water ?? Not enough water , so dry hard to stir

    1. Hey Lee-Anne. Sounds like you have more flour than 4 cups? The quantity is right. It should not be dry. In fact, quite wet. You can certainly add more water if necessary.