You may also like

5 from 43 votes (8 ratings without comment)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating




155 Comments

  1. hi veena

    I came across your blog while searching for troubleshooting smbc. your blog is very detailed with tips and tricks. thank you for such a lovely blog.
    I made an smbc with a below recipe measurement
    —2 egg white( 65 gms)
    —sugar 70gms
    —vanilla essence (didnt have extract) 1 tsp
    —unsalted butter 150gms

    followed almost the sane procedure of yours. I got correct texture able to pipe smooth and it tasted good when I made. after a few hours when I tasted it, it was so wierd like I ate plain butter and a mild sweetness came at last. what is the reason I am not able to find out why it was perfect in the beginning and lost sweetness after an hour. kindly clarify me

    thanks
    suji

    1. Hey Suji. Sounds like the meringue lost volume completely or the butter melted. Did you leave it out of the fridge for long? One thing you can do is chill it again for a few minutes, then rewhip and see if you get some volume again.

  2. I am new to making this buttercream, and I have not been sucessful. My first time I did not wash everything down with vinegar so I assume that was why the meringue didn’t make it to stiff peaks . The next time I washed down everything I was using, but I still couldn’t get to stiff peaks . What could I be doing wrong? Sugar crystals??

    1. Debra, I’m sorry to hear that. Well, let’s see.
      1. make sure to separate the eggs properly. Any, yolk (even the tiniest bit) is fat!
      2. Clean equipment but don’t saturate them with vinegar. Just barely wipe them dry. Vinegar can cook the eggs
      3. make sure the eggs are at room temperature but also don’t over temper the eggs. It takes just minutes to temper.
      4. start at a low speed and then increase speed gradually. Otherwise, they will start to whip and them loose volume quickly.
      I hope these tips help.

  3. 5 stars
    Hello Veena, i always loved your recipes. Especially this SMBC , it’s very light in sweet. Does this recipe works with pasteurized egg white? My heart always break while throwing egg yolks ?. Can’t eat so much yolks , as I bake professionally, I make bigger batches @ freeze it most of the time. Thank you so much ?

    1. Thank you, Anushri. I do have a recipe for SMBC with meringue powder. Warming the egg whites is essentially pasteurizing them so technically, you could just add the sugar gradually to the whipping egg whites and then add the butter. Do a small batch and see how it goes. Tweak as needed.

  4. Hi Veena,
    Thank you for your advice not to give up or throw away the buttercream if it’s not going well. I had mine look curdled and almost threw it away but I finally found the solution from your post.
    I read from one of the comments that you can substitute the butter with cream cheese. What is the ratio for this recipe? I tried adding cream cheese on top of the original SBM recipe last time but it became soft. I don’t what went wrong.
    Thanks in advance!

    1. Imelda. Yes,chilling for a few minutes usually does the trick.
      For cream cheese. I use half butter and half full-fat cream cheese (usually 40% mascarpone)
      I add it at the end after I have whipped the buttercream.
      Make sure the cream cheese is room temperature and creamy (to prevent lumps) Then add it and whip until smooth.
      Do not overwhip once you add cream cheese as it can curdle with the meringue.

  5. Can you help me troubleshoot?

    The frosting looked perfect until I added the butter. Now it looks just like cottage cheese. I put it in the fridge. Is there anything I can do to fix it?

    1. Hey Samantha. Yes, putting it in the fridge is the right thing to do at this point. The reason the buttercream looks like cottage cheese simply means that the bowl was still not completely cold when you added the butter. So it melted slightly and looks curdled. Let it cool for a few minutes until whip it until smooth

  6. Karolina Wasson says:

    It turned great ,but now my family wants it less buttery taste . Could I add cream cheese to it ?

    1. Yes you can add some ful-fat cream cheese to it after the butter. Whip it less after you add the cream cheese otherwise it will curdle.

  7. Hi Veena! I have a couple questions for you, if you have time to answer.
    1) What’s the minimum amount of sugar you can add and still get the meringue to hold up? My family loves SMBC, and I’ve made it multiple times from other recipes, but even the usual SMBC tends to be a bit too sweet for our palate. At the same time, I’m always scared to use less sugar since I know that it’s necessary for the meringue to stabilize. Can I use less than the 1 cup of sugar or will the meringue collapse?
    2) How many portions would you suggest making for a 13×18 sheet cake with 2 layers of cake? I don’t usually make such big cakes, so I’m scared I won’t have enough cream to ice it all.

    1. Hey Jessica,
      Ideally, to be safe more sugar is better to hold the meringue. So 1 cup for every 4 egg whites is the standard.
      Also, the addition of butter being fat weakens the meringue

      You can try using 3/4 cup of sugar next time. In most cases, it should work.
      What you can do, is instead of letting it cool to room temperature on the counter chill the meringue for a few minutes in the fridge before you add the butter.
      This might help prevent it from deflating.

      The amount of frosting on a cake is really dependent on how thick or thin you like to fill and frost your cakes. I’d use at least 3X these recipes for a large sheet cake with filling.

      Also, if you like things less sweet use less sweet fillings such as vanilla pastry cream cake filling instead of buttercream.

  8. Hi Veena,
    Every time I’ve made this the past few days, my meringue has refused to stay at stiff peaks. The first time, it wouldn’t peak. The next time, I was sure to make sure there was no grease anywhere and fully cleaned all surfaces, and it managed to reach stiff peaks, but it was hot, so i left it to cool for 20 minutes on counter top. When I went back I did not pay attention if the meringue was still stiff or deflated. I added a tablespoon of butter and as soon as I whipped it felt soupy and no matter how much refrigerating after that I am not able to make it reach frosting consistency. Do you have any tips? I have no clue what I’ve done wrong, I checked the troubleshooting guide but could not be sure how to troubleshoot. Can you please help salvage this!

    1. Anitha. If the meringue does not become stiff peaks perhaps there is grease in the bowl. Please see the tips and troubleshooting in the post. Also, the meringue may deflate slightly as soon as you add the butter but it will become light and fluffy as you continue with the recipe. However, if you have a soupy liquid perhaps the meringue was not cooled enough. You can place it in the fridge for 20 minutes then whip it until light and fluffy. I hope this helps.

      1. Thank you so much for your quick reply. I will try again soon.

  9. Jayne Mansfield says:

    Do you use unsweetened chocolate to make the chocolate buttercream? Or what would you recommend?

    1. Jayne, I like to use dark chocolate about 70% cocoa. But, you can use any chocolate you want! Even up to 90%

  10. Usha shrestha says:

    My meringue was quite good. It was cool as well but when I added butter, its volume drastically decreased and finally got into fine chunks with separation of water. Can you please help?

    1. It does sound like the butter melted which means it was not cool yet. Just place it in the fridge for a few minutes then whip until light and fluffy