You may also like

5 from 43 votes (8 ratings without comment)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating




155 Comments

  1. My buttercream becomes soft outside/ at room temperature.. can I add meringue powder to stabilise it ?
    If yes, at what point & how much & in powder form or should I dilute it first ?

    1. Venti, meringue powder will not do much good if the weather is warm or humid. Meringue buttercream has lots of butter, which is affected by temperature, so if it’s warm, the butter will melt. You must keep the buttercream in the fridge as much as possible or opt for a frosting with less butter or with powdered sugar.

  2. Hi Veena
    Thanks for the recipe with great tips. Should I pour the whipped egg whites and sugar from the double boiler bowl into a fresh bowl for beating, to help minimize the risk of the mixture being too warm when adding butter? Thanks!

    1. Hey Romy, I use the stand mixer bowl over my pot of boiling water. And then, I use the same bowl to whip the egg whites with sugar. The bowl will cool as it continues to whip. Only once cooled add the butter.

  3. Hi Veena, thank you so much for your reply. Yes, I already tried everything you suggest in your post. So I wonder if there is something else I can do to transform this concoction of sugar, egg whites and butter? Another kind of frosting maybe, or a weird cake? 🙂
    Unless you know of something else I could try, besides whipping again? I set aside about 2 cups of the stuff and have added more butter and then added cocoa, just to see if it would keep some structure, but no. I keep wondering how the meringue was so very thick and there is no structure at all, only when it’s frozen.
    For future reference, is there a point of no return if the egg whites with sugar were beaten too much and the meringue became so very thick? I should not have trusted my thermometer, I believe. 🙁

    1. Adding more butter will not help, It will make it greasier. Over-beaten egg whites can deflate. But in this case, it looks like the eggs did whip into a good meringue and even stayed well after the butter was added.
      If you added more butter the only thing you can do is add some powdered sugar and whip again. It will be sweeter but it may become spreadable. Thanks

      1. Thanks, and I will let you know if anything changes.

  4. Hello Veena, I just found your website a few weeks ago and love your detailed recipes. So I tried making the SMBC and it came out great that time. But now I have 2 failed attempts sitting in my freezer. I have tried everything that anyone suggests, from heating a portion and beating again, or to cool it before whipping again. All I know is that the egg whites DID beat stiff but wondered if too stiff. Also wondered if it could be that I left too long over the double boiler and that’s why they beat up so stiff? Each batch looked like it was going to come together and then it would deflate. There is no stability; looks like a thick, smooth cake batter!
    Do you have any suggestions of what I could try on a portion of what I have in freezer? Even if it’s something to bake or another type of frosting? I would really appreciate your help; trying so hard not to waste. 🙁

    1. Hey Mary, Sorry to hear you are having issues with SMBC. Have you tried the troubleshooting issues that I have suggested in the post? Those are usually the most common reasons why many have issues with SMBC. As for the freezing, do you thaw in the fridge overnight and then whip until it holds peaks again? Also, make sure that the buttercream does not melt (butter in the whipped egg whites) before you freeze that. That can cause the buttercream to become greasy and not fluffy up. I hope this helps.