You may also like

5 from 386 votes (78 ratings without comment)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating




750 Comments

  1. 5 stars
    Tried this recipe for the first time and obviously I must be doing something wrong. I combined the liquid ingredients with the powdered sugar and worked it in until the sugar was gone and it was still beyond sticky, like straight up gooey. I kneaded in the vegetable shortening and it helped for a moment with the stickiness but any working with it whatsoever and the stickiness would come back. So I kneaded in more sugar. And more sugar. And more sugar. Kneaded in more shortening. All that would help for maybe a minute and then once the shortening or sugar really worked in it would become glue again. It said not to use too much sugar because it will stiffen with the gelatin, but it was a soft mess of glue no matter how much sugar I kneaded in. It also had a “grainy”/shaggy/lumpy look when stretched rather than being a smooth surface. Maybe you have some ideas where I went wrong because it is completely unworkable and un useable as is.

    1. Hey Jessika. I know fondant is not the easiest thing to make. Being a professional cake decorator, this recipe has been my go-to for many years and if you look below in the comments, you will see many have had successes and failures too.
      In your case, is it possible, you added the stuff very hot to the powdered sugar so it might have melted? It should be barely warm
      Also, could it be possible that the gelatin was overcooked so it lost elasticity?
      Make sure to use powdered sugar made from cane, not beet sugar. Beet sugar stays grainy.
      I hope this helps, please feel free to ask any more questions if you have.
      Thanks

      1. Thanks for the feedback! I think I see what happened. I missed the part where you chill the gelatin mixture. I saw it in the instructions during my read-through to familiarize myself with the recipe, but then I think I forgot about it during the process. I’ll definitely try it again with the chill part of it and change the powdered sugar – see if that helps, In general I love your stuff! I’ve had a lot of success with your recipes which is why I chose this one to try for making fondant. Sorry if the frustration came through a bit in the post. The fondant was a mess, I’d obviously screwed up but couldn’t figure out what was going wrong, the kitchen was a sticky mess and right in the middle of the whole thing the water in our building was turned off for maintenance so it wasn’t a great moment.

        1. That’s ok Jessika. I understand. It’s all good.
          I have been there. My initial years as a cake decorator drove me crazy. Unfortunately, back then we didn’t have many people sharing recipes as they do these days. We had fewer options so we had to figure it as we go.
          Yes, cooling the gelatin is important but also make sure you don’t put the cooled gelatin in the powdered sugar as it can also seize up immediately and become small grains. So do it slowly. Similar to tempering. Add a little powdered sugar to the gelatin – combine and add more. I hope that makes sense.

  2. Hello, I will be making fondant for the first time and I am having a hard time finding meringue powder in stock nearby. Will the recipe work without it or is there a substitute I can use? Thank you so much for the great recipe and detailed instructions. Hopefully I will be able to get a good result. Thanks again!

    1. Hey Anelia, You can omit the meringue powder. It does help in hot and humid climates but adding a bit more stability. But, it works great without it too,

      1. Hi Veena, I made the fondant using your recipe and it turned out great. Everyone loved the cake and were surprised when they found out it was homemade. Thanks again for all of your help! I tried a couple of other fondant recipes before this one and I can honestly say that yours is the best!

        1. Thank you, Anelia. I am so happy to hear that. Appreciate you coming back to write this feedback.

  3. Jacqueline Foster says:

    How long does it keep when made? Also do I colour it once it’s made?
    Thanks

    1. Jacqueline. you can color the whole batch when you are making it or you can make white fondant. Then color small portions as you need. It is easy to color fondant with gel food colors.

  4. Jasmyn Rowe says:

    Does it have to be a non-dairy cream?

    1. Well, non-dairy means you can leave it out for long hours even in hot and humid conditions. Dairy may not do so well in hot cilamate. But, yes, you can use dairy as well.

  5. 5 stars
    Love this recipe. This will be my go to from now on. Came out perfect the first time. Thank you for sharing!!!

  6. 5 stars
    Great recipe. Thank you!?

  7. Can you store your cake in the refrigerator after covering it with this fondant.

    1. Yes, you can Natasha. In some places, humidity may cause condensation which will dry out. Best, not to touch condensation as it can leave fingerprints when it dries out. Hope this helps

  8. Hi! I jz wanna ask for it is ok to replace meringue powder to egg white instead?

  9. God's Glory Wisdom says:

    First of all, I want to start by thanking u for your generosity in releasing such detailed and enormous information on fondant making. It has settled a lot of questions and given me better understanding too. I still have few more questions whose answers I believe will help achieve smooth and perfect fondant.
    1. From ur recipe, I can see u added meringue. What is its effect on fondant and can it be totally left out if not easily found in my location?
    2. What is the effect of liquid glucose on fondant? I thought it’s for elasticity but from ur notes, u said gelatin is for elasticity.
    3. I realized CMC wasn’t included to ur first recipe. Why? And what is the effect of CMC on fondant.

    Thank you one again for your kindness and generosity

    1. 1. Meringue gives the fondant a crust that works great in hot and humid places.
      2. Both glucose and gelatin help with elasticity. Glycerin helps it keep it soft.
      3. CMC adds stability but it can also make the fondant hard and dry. So in some fondants, we use it.

  10. Vicki Lynn Bishop says:

    How much does this recipe make please? I would like to use the table you provided to determine how much Fondant is needed to cover my cakes, I need to know how many ounces or pounds does this recipe make? Thank you!