You may also like

5 from 34 votes (7 ratings without comment)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating




67 Comments

  1. 5 stars
    Hello again😊
    Can you please clarify, do you whip the powdered egg whites to stiff peaks before you add the sugar syrup ( as when using fresh egg whites) or am I reading correctly your instructions above as, you just mix the powdered egg whites, water and cream of tarter for a couple minutes ( not necessarily until peaks form) then add the hot sugar syrup,then beat until stiff peaks form?

    1. 5 stars
      Hi J,

      You’re reading the instructions correctly. With this version made using meringue powder, I do not whip the mixture to stiff peaks before adding the hot sugar syrup.

      I simply whisk the meringue powder, water, and cream of tartar together for a couple of minutes until foamy. Then I slowly stream in the hot sugar syrup and continue whipping until the mixture becomes thick, glossy, reaches stiff peaks, and has cooled.

      The process is a little different from traditional Italian meringue made with fresh egg whites, but the end result is very similar.

      I hope that helps clarify things!

  2. 5 stars
    Hi Veena,
    If I am making a 3 tier wedding cake (10″, 8″, 6″ tiers, at least 4″ high each, with an icing dam to containe a thickened fruit filling between layers of each tier) how many batches of this Italian Meringue Buttercream do you think I will need to make? ( I may or may not cover with fondant, I have not decided yet.)

    1. 5 stars
      Hi J,

      For a 3-tier cake with 10-inch, 8-inch, and 6-inch tiers that are about 4 inches tall, I’d plan on approximately 4 to 5 batches of this buttercream, depending on how much frosting you use between the layers and whether you’ll be covering the cake with fondant.

      If you’re using fondant, you’ll need less buttercream for the final coating, so 4 batches is usually sufficient. If you’re finishing the cake entirely in buttercream, I’d make 5 batches to be safe.

      I always prefer having a little extra rather than running short during assembly.

  3. 5 stars
    Hello Veena,
    Can this recipe be doubled right from the start or is it better to make multiple batches separately?

    1. 5 stars
      Hi J,

      Yes, this recipe can be doubled, provided your mixer is large enough to handle the volume. For best results, I usually prefer making multiple batches when working on large cakes, as it gives you more control over the meringue and syrup. If your mixer is at or near capacity, I’d definitely make separate batches.

      Happy baking!

  4. 5 stars
    hi, Veena! I was wondering if you knew a work around for this recipe without butter?

    1. Hi Mary, yes, you can make this without butter, but the texture will be a little different. Italian meringue buttercream relies heavily on butter for its silky, stable texture.

      You can try:

      vegetable shortening for a more stable frosting (great in warm weather)
      a mix of shortening and cream cheese for a lighter flavor
      or whipped white chocolate ganache if you want something less buttery but still smooth and pipeable.

      That said, if you simply want less butter flavor, I often reduce the butter slightly and add a little extra meringue instead of removing it completely. Hope that helps!

  5. I tried making this recipe and I think I might have messed up somewhere because it’s not whipping up nicely anymore after 5 minutes of adding in the syrup into the meringue powder. It looks like cottage cheese. I haven’t added in the butter yet.

    1. I’m so sorry this happened to your Brooke. How upsetting.
      It sounds like the meringue collapsed before it had a chance to whip properly. When the mixture looks curdled or “like cottage cheese,” it usually means the syrup went in too fast or too hot, so the meringue powder slurry couldn’t build stable volume.

      Here’s what you can try next time:

      Add the syrup very slowly in a thin, steady stream, and keep mixing on medium-high.

      Make sure the syrup has reached the correct temperature — too hot and it can deflate the meringue powder.

      Once all the syrup is added, keep whipping. It can take a few extra minutes for it to come together.

      If it’s still loose and curdled-looking, sadly it won’t turn into buttercream — but it’s fixable next time with a slower pour and slightly cooler syrup.

      Let me know exactly how you added the syrup and I can help you troubleshoot step-by-step.

  6. Could i make this using brown cane sugar if i am going to color the buttercream anyway? (i dont have granulated sugar on hand)

    1. I have not tried it with brown sugar, so I don’t know if this will work. Sorry.

  7. Just to be clear, the sugar used in the meringue (¼ cup (50 g) Sugar), is it granulated or powdered/icing sugar?

  8. Can I use granulated sugar with the meringue before pouring in the syrup? Or does it need to be powdered sugar? Can’t wait to try it!

      1. In the comment before this you said it should be granulated, not powdered. Can you clarify?

        1. The recipe says granulated sugar. That’s what it must be granulated sugar. Thanks

  9. 5 stars
    Hi Veena,
    I absolutely love this recipe and how easy it is to make. I used half butter and half shortening, the texture, taste and consistency is good especially right out of the fridge (nice and stiff for piping). The only problem is if it’s a bit warm, some pipings start to wilt or it falls right off my spatula..is that normal?? I could pipe flowers beautifully when it’s still cold but it starts to soften quickly. Is there anything I can do?

    Thank you for the recipe!

    1. Thanh. Meringue-based buttercreams are high in fat and whipped eggs both these are sensitive to heat. So, obviously, as soon as you bring them out of the fridge they start to react to the temperature. The hotter it sooner it will become soft. You can try keeping the room cold as possible by turning the Air conditioning on high. Also, note that you can pipe with chilled buttercream but if not kept chilled they will become soft overtime as well.