You may also like

5 from 34 votes (7 ratings without comment)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating




67 Comments

  1. Kristi Short says:

    5 stars
    Hi Veena! I’m so thankful to have found you on Pinterest! During all of this Covid I’ve found my new job.. baking cakes. I’ve always loved to bake but now I’m starting my own business. I use your fondant recipe to make my cake toppers and now I’m trying out this Italian meringue buttercream with meringue powder for this weekend. Thank you so much for your yummy recipes! ❤️

    1. Thank yoy, Kristi. I am so happy to hear that my recipes are useful. Thank you for the feedback and all the best with you new business

  2. Gita Clara Montana says:

    5 stars
    Hi veena! Thanks for sharing this recipe, i have tried this recipe few times, it works, but my IMBC result is not really as stable as i want. I have also follow your recipe step-by-step. I live in Bali, it’s very hot and humid in here (around 32C on daytime),and my IMBC always melt after i use to frost my cake. Also, whenever i stored it in fridge to use later, it always loose its consistency. It cannot even hold its shape anymore, it’s like almost melted, even after i whipped it really well. Do i need to add more butter/shortening? Please answer this, because i really love this buttercream and would like to try again. Thanks 😉

    1. Hey Gita. I think the issue is the weather, not the recipe. Sounds like you are doing the recipe correctly and if the weather is hot then the meringue in the buttercream will deflate. The only option is to keep it cold in the fridge as much as possible. When you get it out you can whip it back to consistency. If you add more butter or shortening it will be too buttery and lose the lightness from the meringue.

      1. Gita Clara Montana says:

        Hi, thank you for your fast reply, i notice that with freshly made batch, the IMBC can hold its shape and quite stable, but the problem occurs after i stored it in the fridge. It just lost its consistency, and almost soupy-like. But i will try to use it right away then. Again, thank you for your help.

        1. Sounds like the egg protein separates in the fridge. Try to use cream of tartar when whipping the egg whites. It helps stabilize them and prevents separation.

  3. 5 stars
    I’m not sure what I did wrong. The whites were stiff and glossy then I added the sugar mixture and it looked fine (it was at soft ball stage). I continued to add the room temperature butter in cubes. I only got about 2 cups of frosting not 5. It also tastes super buttery and you can feel the sugar texture in it. Any suggestions on what I could have done wrong to get this outcome?

    1. Hey Madi. Sounds like the sugar got crystalized which is why you could feel the sugar texture in it. Did you use a thermometer?
      If you don’t have a thermometer please make Swiss Meringue Buttercream.
      Meringue buttercreams are definitely more buttery than American buttercreams but sounds like your meringue was deflated too.

  4. 5 stars
    HI!
    I’ve tried to make this multiple of times, yet I’m unable to. I am able to whip up the eggwhites/meringue powder into stiff peaks before adding the simple sugar. However, once I add the simple sugar the mixture never whips up. I am using a hand mixer, and I mixed for an hour before but it didn’t work.

    What can I do about this?

    1. Hey Joanna.
      Not sure I understand the problem. Are you getting the temperature of the sugar to 238F? Once you add the sugar does the meringue loose volume? or become more liquid?
      If you have already reached meringue consistency, you don’t need more volume when you add sugar but you should not lose any.
      If you have reached stiff peaks – you can add butter once the meringue is cooled.
      Hope this helps…. feel free to ask again if I didn’t answer your concern.
      Thanks

      1. Hi veena! Thanks for responding!
        I am getting the sugar syrup up to 238 degrees.
        After i add the sugar syrup to the stiffed egg whites, the mixture becomes like glue. I keep trying to mix it until it reaches stiff peaks so i can add butter, but it just stays in a glue like consistency

        1. So sorry Joanna. I’m not sure what the problem could be because – you say the meringue is already reached its volume and the syrup is the right consistency.
          Keep in mine – meringue is egg whites so yes, it should look shiny and sticky. Then when you add butter it becomes a buttercream. Until then it is just sticky meringue. Which can be piped and baked as meringue.
          If this does not work, I would encourage you to make a Swiss meringue buttercream instead of Italian meringue

          1. HI veena! Thanks for trying to help!

            So the meringue (syrup and egg whites) do NOT need to stiffen before addjng the butter??

            1. They will not add much volume if they were already stiff – but they will be fluffy, shiny and yes sticky. But, if you piped they should be able to hold peaks on the baking tray. Hope that helps.

          2. Hi Veena,

            So the meringue is just liquidy with the consistency of glue. It doesnt fluff up and if i were to pipe it, it would not be able to keep its form. What do I do about this?

            1. Hey Joanna. I’m sorry – not sure what is happening at your end.
              Usually, meringue not whipping up is the result of grease – but you say that you reached stiff peaks before adding the sugar syrup.
              Another reason would be that the sugar syrup did not reach to 238 F or was added too early – but you say the sugar is the right temperature.
              If both these are correct then they should be no reason why the meringue is not whipping up.
              Unfortunately, I think this is a wasted batch. I did make a video for this recipe last week and I hope to update this post with a recipe video soon.
              If possible I’d highly recommend you start with a fresh batch –
              Also, I’d recommend you make a Swiss meringue buttercream first so you see the consistency of the meringue and buttercream. Plus it’s a much easier recipe. I already have a video on the post for that recipe.
              I’m sorry about this batch… I can imagine this is frustrating…. but we’ve all been there (even the best of us) and had those meringue batches that don’t whip up so don’t’ take it too hard on yourself. Hugs

  5. Lianne Hilbert says:

    Hi Veena! Thank you for posting this! I’ve been looking for a buttercream recipe where I can use up my meringue powder and this looks perfect! I couldn’t find the first recipe – the one with the the candy thermometer. I’ve checked a couple times in case I missed it, but I think the first recipe was accidentally deleted. What temperature do you want to reach with a candy thermometer?
    Thanks,
    Lianne

    1. hey Lianne. Thank you for bringing this to my attention. Not sure why but that second recipe card keeps popping out of the post. I may need to make a new post for it. I have added it now and will work on it this week. Thanks

  6. Hello! Excited to try this recipe! Is there any chance you have weight measurements for the granulated sugar? 🙂

    1. Hey Jackie – 1 cup sugar is 200 grams and 1/4 cup is 50 grams – so that 250 grams.

      1. Hi Veena,
        Thank you so much! Will post back the results when I make it 😀

  7. Christine says:

    If I’m making this without a candy thermometer, do I want to use soft ball or firm ball? The division between the two of those is at 245 F, so do I err low or high?

    1. If you do not have a candy thermometer I suggest you use the second method and tips shared in there. I would say err on the low not high side of the tmeperature

  8. Bernadette Niebuhr says:

    5 stars
    Hello,

    Does this frosting require refrigeration. I am opening a Cottage Food business and items that require refrigeration are not allowed. I really appreciate your time and your response.

    1. You can keep a cake frosted in this buttercream out of the fridge for two to three days – keep left over frosting in the fridge. Hope that helps.

  9. Bubborina says:

    5 stars
    Dear Veena,
    I tried the buttercream without using the candy thermometer and loved it! The only issue I had was when brought back to room temp after I had refrigerated it overnight, it turned ivory in color upon whipping and lost its fluffy consistency.
    Thanks!

    1. Not sure why it turned to ivory – perhaps since you lost fluffiness the color of the butter became more prominent? Not sure just guessing lol

  10. 5 stars
    Can i substitute cream of tartar instead of meringue powder for “meringue buttercream without candy thermometer”?. Because cream of tartar is more affordable and readily available. thank you.

    1. No. Cream of tartar and meringue are not the same thing! You need to find meringue powder or make swiss meringue buttercream with real egg whites.