You may also like

5 from 386 votes (78 ratings without comment)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating




750 Comments

  1. Hi!

    Can I replace the shortening with coconut oil, and the corn syrup with honey? I have used these replacements in other recipes (including candy making) with great results but am a complete novice when it comes to fondant and don’t want to ruin it. Thank you so much for this recipe and the detailed instructions!

    1. Hey Paige. Honey does not work the same way as corn syrup. You can use glucose instead of corn syrup. You can use coconut oil nut the fondant will have a coconut flavor.

  2. Kristine Gaertner says:

    Hi. I’m going to use your recipe for a Halloween birthday cake. I’m confused though. There’s one method in this blog and a different on YouTube. This one the shortening is kneaded in and the meringue goes in the powdered sugar. YouTube shortening is dissolved into the warm cream/gelatin mix and meringue goes in there as well. Which one works best?

    1. Kristine. In both the meringue is added to the powdered sugar, not cream. It is best to knead the fondant with the shortening otherwise you will use extra powdered sugar

  3. 1 1/2 tablespoons of gelatin is 14 grams not 22 grams can you correct that because 22 gram looks like is 2 1/3 tablespoon

  4. 5 stars
    Can one use sheet gelatin instead of powdered gelatin.

    This has become my go to fondant icing recipe. It really works and is a great flavour

    1. Sue, I have not used sheet gelatin with this recipe.. I’ve always used powdered because it works well for me. I’m happy you like this recipe too.

  5. I was wondering if agar agar can be substituted for the gelatin in this specific recipe and if the meringue is necessary? I have an egg allergy but wanted to use this recipe instead of the vegetarian.

      1. Will there be any noticeable textural differences?

        1. No, it looks like sugar paste. The stretch is less because agar agar does not have the same elasticity as fondant.

          1. Thank you so much!!

  6. 5 stars
    Your recipe for fondant is the best I have ever tried. Tasty, best performing as far as rolling out thinly if needed, and elasticity without tearing. Also, your buttercream recipes are great tasting, best performing. easy to use. Your recipes are spot on; quality ingredients, ease of making, great tasting. I’m looking forward to exploring your other recipes. Glad I found you!

  7. Can I use meringue powder mix instead of meringue powder?

    1. Meringue powder mix I believe has powdered sugar added to it. You can use it or you can omit the meringue powder. The recipe works either ways, Dolly.

  8. Venita Godinho says:

    Does non dairy liquid creamer mean whipping cream?

    1. You can use whipping cream but the shelf life is shorter. Non-dairy is liquid cream often used for coffee.

  9. Yvonne Yourkowski says:

    Sorry I also forgot to add that after kneading I have the elasticity but when I take out of fridge it is mostly gone. I’m not sure how much extra glycerin I should be adding or what I have done wrong?

    1. I think if you solve the previous issue with the gelatin it will give you more elasticity.

  10. Yvonne Yourkowski says:

    I really like your recipe but I get these little pieces of gelatin in my fondant. Why is it doing that? Am I heating it too much or not enough? Thanks

    1. Yvonne, sounds like you are adding the gelatin when it’s quite cool to the powdered sugar. So as soon as it hits the sugar it cools and balls up. I hope that makes sense. Make sure the gelatin is warm not cold when you add it to the sugar.

      1. Yvonne Yourkowski says:

        Thanks. I tried again I heated up 35 seconds the first time and then mixed everything and did another 10 seconds to warm it up and I still got some of the chunks. I don’t think as many as before, I’m just afraid to heat up any longer cause you say up above to only heat 30 seconds and don’t overheat because you could wreck it.

        1. The gelatin is supposed to melt completely, Yvonne. If that means you need more than 30 seconds, I guess you can do it.
          If necessary add some of the powder sugar to the gelatin (as in the tempering method) Then add it to the rest of the sugar if that helps combine without making it into lumps.