You may also like

4.97 from 33 votes (22 ratings without comment)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating




87 Comments

  1. Wilma Barbosa Fagundes says:

    Yes, thank you. ,ve just tried to make it and I have a doubt, I live in Italy and I was not certain if 10 tsp of meringue powder mean teaspoons or Tablespoons. I decided to use teaspoons and make only half the recipe even if I had prepared the butter for a full recipe. It NEVER got whipped. Stand mixer and handmixer. So I came to read the instructions (I have the recipe stamped in my cake-decoration book) again but I could not solve my doubt.

    1. I’m sorry to hear that, Wilma. The meringue powder does take a while to whip up but make sure that there is no grease in the bowl otherwise the meringue will not whip. And yes, tsp it is teaspoons.

  2. Carla J Gaiser says:

    5 stars
    Everyone loved it!

  3. Hi Veena, my meringue/butter mixture is really soupy. I whisked the egg white mixture until I got stiff peaks and the mixing bowl felt cool before I added my room temperature butter. Pretty much as soon as I added the butter the meringue just deflated. I tried sticking into the fridge and rewhipping for a long time but it’s still super runny.
    What did I do wrong please? Can this still be saved?

    1. If it is still runny means the butter was added too soon and it is still not cold enough. Chill it well, then switch to a paddle attachment and whip it until light and fluffy. If you loose volume from the egss, you my need to add a little powdered sugar. But you will be able to use it.

  4. JanessaNadeau says:

    Hello I’ve made this twice now, and my meringue isn’t whipping to stiff peaks…. I am adding the butter when it’s soft peaks. then the butter melts and is chunky. I put it in the fridge and tried to re-whip… it just looks like chunky separated butter. Any hope? There’s also like a white watery substance that doesn’t want to mix back in. I guess it broke?

    1. If it is soup consistency means you added the butter too early and the meringue has melted the butter. You need to put it in the fridge for a few minutes until it is cooler and then whip it again.
      The white watery substance means the egg whites have separated from the protein. You can try whipping it.

  5. After adding my butter it’s chunky and greasy. I put in fridge to cools and whipped again and there’s like white egg soup floating that won’t incorporate

    1. If it is soup consistency means you added the butter too early and the meringue has melted the butter. You need to put it in the fridge for a few minutes until it is cooler and then whip it again.

  6. I’ve done the meringue powder and sugar over a double boiler and am now whipping it in my stand mixer. It’s taking ages and will not whip like a meringue. What have I done wrong???? My bowls were clean and I used the exact measurements. Please help!

    1. Anne, Sorry not sure. But, the most common mistake people make is. Don’t clean the bowl and whisk properly. Or they don’t mix it enough on the double boiler until it becomes sticky like egg whites.
      I would say whip a few minutes more and see if works. Check to see if the egg white powder is good.

    2. Thank you Veena. I think that’s what happened – I didn’t whip long enough in double boiler although it was 160°F. However when it didn’t come to stiff peaks in the stand mixer, I still added the butter and it turned out great. Maybe a little greasy but went on the cake like a dream. I’m very happy with the results and will make sure I whip it longer next time as I’ll certainly be using this method again. Thanks so much ????

  7. Can I use this buttercream under fondant or is it too soft?

  8. Hi, I’d like to make a marshmallow-like frosting similar to a 7 minute. Can I just follow this recipe & not add the butter, or will I have to adjust the amounts of the ingredients?

    Thanks

  9. Hello Veena,
    Love your recipes. What do you mean those who enjoy a good weather can even keep it out of the fridge for 2 days? I have a friend who woudl like a smbc but she cannot put it in the fridge due to a surprise party. I thought powdered egg whites would be safer than fresh egg whites. She would collect cake on Friday morning and eat it on Saturday evening for a small party. What’s your advice?

    1. Danica. In warm weather, egg whites become softer even when whipped with meringue powder. You can do a test and see how it works for you. I think Friday morning up to Saturday morning might work in a cool dry place.

      1. Hello Veena, temperature is about 20C. The cake would be filled with smbc and then covered in American buttercream and sugarpaste….I might tell her to put some ice packs around cake box, would that make it any better?