You may also like

4.90 from 28 votes (12 ratings without comment)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating




35 Comments

  1. richard schmidt says:

    2 stars
    the cake looks very undone-i baked it for 50 minuted-is there a typo in the ingredients??? it says 1 eggs ( plural??) but the illustrationn looks like more than one egg

    1. No Richard, the cake was not underdone for me. The recipe has two large eggs. In the pictures, you see more eggs because I made a double batch. Please follow the written recipe. Thanks

  2. Cindy Alger says:

    Is it not necessary to peel the peaches for this recipe? Does it depend on what type of peach is being used? Thank you.

    1. Hey Cindy. Yes, I do not peel the peaches for this recipe. I have always made this without peeling and no one ever has had any complaints. I have made this recipe with nectarines, apricots, and plums the same way.

  3. Ankita Upadhyay says:

    Pastry Day 13 Done….

  4. 5 stars
    It’s a winner and I tried it with tinned peaches, just the one tin of 400g needed as they are sweet already, drained them pressed the juice out slightly from each slice. Cake was done after 45mins. It does come out looking quite moist and even a knife test will come out a little wet almost like it’s not done yet. But don’t worry once it has completely cooled it’s transformed into a perfect sponge with an incredible crisp edge. Excellent recipe. Thank you!! Oh and didn’t even need a whisk to mix the cake batter I did it with a spoon it all came together pretty quickly so it meant less mixing = less dense cake.

    1. I am so happy you enjoyed this recipe, Kully. Thank you for the detailed feedback.

  5. Shatzie_D says:

    I tried making this recipe and it literally fell apart. The peaches are too heavy. The recipe calls for four peaches, i used three, and it was too heavy for the cake. I could tell it was not firming up and baked it an additional 20 minutes-still fell apart when I inverted it. It was BEYOND moist- soggy, really. There is no way the picture associated with this recipe is of four peaches worth of peaches. Count the visible slices. It is more than likely less than two. The taste is delicious! But the cake is a hot mess.

    1. Sorry to hear that Shatzie.
      4 medium peaches for an 8-inch cake is correct. But you must cut them into thinner slices. Which is why I suggested 8 slices per peach.
      The batter is a butter-based cake so while it is heavy it still is the perfect sponge cake to hold all those fruits when you flip the cake.
      The only time the cake would be soggy as you say, is if you used soft ripe fruit that completely disintegrated at the bottom after cooking. Which is why I recommend using ripe but firm peaches.
      I’m sorry your cake didn’t turn out but I rechecked the recipe and it look correct. Some have tried it successfully too.
      Thank you for the feedback.

  6. It would be nice if people commenting actually MADE the cake/pie/whatever. That’s what we want to read about – not how nice it looks, sounds, etc.
    DUH!

    1. Hey Mimi.
      Yes, it is always nice to have people come back and let you know how the recipe was. This cake has perhaps only 3 or 4 people who have come back to leave feedback. Often people are motivated to write a comment when they need to clarify a doubt. I wish more people would take the trouble to give feedback.
      BUT, I appreciate all the comments. Often these are people who visit my blog regularly and are happy to say a kind word of support and appreciation for my recipes.
      These keep me motivated to share more and I know that there is someone on the other side reading my recipes.
      Thank you for stopping by – if you do try any of my recipes your feedback would be appreciated.

  7. Patrick Fox says:

    5 stars
    Just made the cake and enjoyed piece too! Awesome!!
    Foxie

  8. 5 stars
    The cake looks so moist and flavorful. There’s always something so special about upside down cakes and the combination with a hot cup of tea is Fabulous. I love the pairing with peach and would try soon.