You may also like

4.84 from 12 votes (5 ratings without comment)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating




16 Comments

  1. 3 stars
    These did not turn out great. First, the dry ingredients had a hard time folding into the “wet” ingredients. It was a crumbly mess until I added a touch of water, then it came together like cookie dough. Once baked, they didn’t spread at all. And it took about 15 minutes to get slightly golden on the bottom. They tasted alright but something is missing in this recipe I think.

    1. Yes, Megan. If you look at the video, the dough is crumbly at first, but it does come together eventually because it has butter.
      Adding water will, of course, spread the cookies out like pancakes.
      Condensed milk has a milky sweet flavor of its own, which is why my kids love it so much.
      But, flavor is subjective, so I’m sorry you didn’t enjoy them.

  2. Hannah L. says:

    5 stars
    Love how simple and tasty these cookies. Husband and family loved them! The only comment keeping me from 5 stars is the instruction regarding rolling the balls in powdered sugar. I rolled the entire ball in powdered sugar, which burns easily in heat, resulting in burnt crumbly rings at the base of these cookies. I’d suggest chilling for at least 45 minutes and leaving a small area of the balls uncovered in powdered sugar before baking, to avoid burnt bottoms.

    1. Hannah, it is normal to have a little caramelization on the bottom of the cookie from the powdered sugar. It will burn only if you over-baked the cookies. Thanks

  3. It says in the directions mix salt with flour, etc. but there is no sign of salt in the ingredients list? Please clarify. thanks

  4. 5 stars
    As always another perfect recipe that the family loved! So easy and tasty!!

  5. 5 stars
    I never met a cookie I didn’t like and they were no exception! So dangerously delicious that I recommend making them with others in the house so you don’t end up eating them all, haha!

  6. Annie @ Annie's Noms says:

    5 stars
    I seriously need to make these! I was actually looking at making condensed milk cookies the other week, but I ended up making something else. I do love condensed milk so much, I can just have spoonfuls of it! These look so soft and tasty, I love how few ingredients there are too!

    1. Oh yes, I can have condensed milk by the spoon too, Annie. These are very addictive you must try.

  7. thisiswholesome says:

    5 stars
    these were so easy to put together and so tasty!

  8. 5 stars
    I love everything made with condensed milk. It makes any recipe so special. And these cookies are a great proof!