You may also like

5 from 30 votes (11 ratings without comment)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating




53 Comments

  1. 5 stars
    I made 2 of these tarts the day before Thanksgivng. The crumb topping held up perfectly after cooling and covering at room temp overnight. They were absolutely phenomenal. Delicious! Thank you for sharing this recipe.

    1. Thank you so much for the lovely feedback – I am so happy your family enjoyed this tart.

  2. Debbie Kane says:

    I am making 2 of these tarts for Thanksgiving 11/27/25. I will be baking these the day before. Can I leave them at room temperature covered overnight without becoming soggy or should I refrigerate them? Thanks!

    1. You can absolutely bake them the day before! Just let the tarts cool completely, then keep them covered at room temperature. The crumble actually holds up really well and won’t go soggy overnight. No need to refrigerate unless your kitchen is very warm, but it’s not necessary in cooler weather. They’ll be perfect for serving the next day! Happy Thanksgiving.

      1. Debbie Kane says:

        Thank you! Happy Thanksgiving to you also.

  3. 5 stars
    My favourite apple tart! I made it many times and I’ve tweaked the recipe a bit. For the apple filling I use only half of the sugar and only half of the quantities for the crumble as it is too much for one tart. I also blind bake the shell so it is more crunchy. I also seal it by brushing some egg yolk in the last minute of blind baking. Thank you for sharing the recipe!

  4. 5 stars
    I plan to make this; it’s looks delicious! I have an eleven inch tart pan; will I need to adjust the pastry ingredients?

  5. 5 stars
    Hi Veena,
    I made this tart Saturday. The tart was extremely delicious. I used Granny Smith, green apples. The textures were perfect, crisp melt in the mouth pastry, soft apple and the crunchy crumble. The tart apples coupled with the lemon gave it a sharp flavor, the nutmeg and cinnamon followed with a cooling sweetness at the end. Truly delightful. I did blind bake the short crust and have not really made sweet short crust pastry. The methods and ratios were different and all was well. Good recipe, I will surely make this again.

  6. Mary-Anne says:

    This looks fantastic. I plan on baking soon. Just checking. Are apple cut in 1/8″ slices or chunks

    1. You can cut them into 1/8 thin slices or small pieces, do not make large chunks. Large chunks will not fit all the apples and when baked the tart won’t have a full look to it as the apples do reduce significantly after baking. Let me know how it was.